Home Gas Prices New York New York City

Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in New York City, NY

Fuel 1

Fuel 1 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 201
29 S Main St
Milltown, NJ
$2.54
Price Reporter Icon DrJarett14 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
Service Station

Reviews

jambrostx's avatar image
jambrostx
Nov 02 2019
Great Review Icon

good service


View Full Station Details
 Details
In & Out Gas

In & Out Gas 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 3
143 Poospatuck Ln
Mastic, NY
$2.59
Price Reporter Icon JMF1573 hours ago

Amenities

Pay At Pump
Air Pump

Reviews

wakddood1966's avatar image
wakddood1966
Dec 02 2024
Bad Review Icon

I got diesel that had gas in it. My truck is in the shop right now


View Full Station Details
 Details
Montauk Native Gasoline

Montauk Native Gasoline 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 624
182 C Poospatuck Ln
Mastic, NY
$2.59
Price Reporter Icon dpginocchio4 hours ago

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Beer

Reviews

Dynamojr's avatar image
Dynamojr
Dec 28 2016
Great Review Icon

Cheepest gas in Suffolk County!!!!!


View Full Station Details
 Details
Fast Gas

Fast Gas 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 322
194 Poospatuck Ln
Mastic, NY
$2.59
Price Reporter Icon smctom8 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms

Reviews

mcxb3r's avatar image
mcxb3r
Nov 27 2019
Bad Review Icon

the gas hustlers in street got to go


View Full Station Details
 Details
Valero

Valero 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 70
5306 US-9W
Newburgh, NY
$2.63
Price Reporter Icon sloppyjoey20153 hours ago

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
Air Pump
Payphone
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Lotto

Reviews

Wendella611's avatar image
Wendella611
May 23 2024
Okay Review Icon

Nice location


View Full Station Details
 Details
Gulf

Gulf 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarEmpty Star
 20
5465 Route 9 W
Newburgh, NY
$2.63
Price Reporter Icon Buddy_q6a3y75811 hours ago

Amenities

Pay At Pump

Reviews

Buddy_ddcxu83q's avatar image
Buddy_ddcxu83q
Aug 06 2024
Great Review Icon

Great prices. Same cash or credit. So close to home!


View Full Station Details
 Details
Flying Arrows Gas

Flying Arrows Gas 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 42
130 Poospatuck Ln
Mastic, NY
$2.64
Price Reporter Icon JMF1573 hours ago

Amenities

C-Store
Air Pump
Full Service

Reviews

Buddy_1g0xzw0f's avatar image
Buddy_1g0xzw0f
Sep 27 2022
Bad Review Icon

This station is a ripoff, the other two stations are a lot cheaper and ceaner


View Full Station Details
 Details
Rez Gas Station

Rez Gas Station 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 9
114 Poospatuck Ln
Mastic, NY
$2.64
Price Reporter Icon JMF1573 hours ago

Amenities

Pay At Pump

Reviews

yakjack55's avatar image
yakjack55
Jul 16 2024
Great Review Icon

Brand new station on the rez matching the other 2 self serve stations in price but it’s at the other enterance so it helps even out the traffic


View Full Station Details
 Details
BP

BP 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 15
565 Amboy Ave
Perth Amboy, NJ
$2.65
Price Reporter Icon devildan1 day ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Service Station
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

samdugan's avatar image
samdugan
Feb 09 2023
Okay Review Icon

Great station, great staff!!


View Full Station Details
 Details
Mobil

Mobil 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 120
345 NJ-18 S
East Brunswick, NJ
$2.65
Price Reporter Icon MW11114 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM

Reviews

kinabina's avatar image
kinabina
Aug 13 2017
Bad Review Icon

Gas attendant didn't give the credit card back while pumping our gas. 👎


View Full Station Details
 Details
Click here to earn instant savings of up to $10 every tank!
Click here to download the GasBuddy App and start saving today!

Local Prices in New York City, NY

You Are Here

 Home Gas Prices New York New York City