GasBuddy
GasBuddy
Log InSign UpFind Gas
 Home Gas Price Search New York Middletown Cumberland Farms (251 Highland Ave)

Cumberland Farms in Middletown (251 Highland Ave)

Cumberland Farms

Cumberland Farms 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 (21)
251 Highland Ave
Middletown, NY 
1 (845) 343-9259

Station Prices

Reported Gas Price

The prices in this row are the prices that members of the GasBuddy community provide.

Prices can also come from store owners and retailer data feeds.

These prices are invaluable to helping one another save the most on fuel!

Regular
Midgrade
Premium
- - -
- - -
- - -
Log In To Report PricesPay With GasBuddy Banner - Never Pay Full Price. Join and save up to 25¢/gal

Station Ratings

3.4
Overall Rating

Features & Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

may4289's avatar image
may4289
Oct 10 2024
Bad Review Icon

This is no longer a gas station for over 2 years.

prgentleman845's avatar image
prgentleman845
Aug 10 2024
Bad Review Icon

Permanently closed

slom42's avatar image
slom42
Jul 17 2023
Bad Review Icon

It is no longer it closed

jknightl's avatar image
jknightl
Sep 01 2022
Great Review Icon

With SmartPay you always get $.10 cents off

jayjaytwb6789's avatar image
jayjaytwb6789
May 06 2022
Okay Review Icon

older style

zoghz's avatar image
zoghz
Feb 26 2020
Great Review Icon

Nice gas station, only has unleaded gas, but cheap price!

TheGasBuddyKing's avatar image
TheGasBuddyKing
Nov 25 2019
Great Review Icon

their coffee is great for its price!

Buddy_gfr3txn6's avatar image
Buddy_gfr3txn6
Aug 21 2019
Bad Review Icon

what is gas buddy?

jfl4's avatar image
jfl4
Aug 15 2019
Great Review Icon

Nicr

mcdowelle's avatar image
mcdowelle
Jul 03 2019
Okay Review Icon

The price shown is a members price.

These reviews are the subjective opinion of a GasBuddy member and not of GasBuddy LLC

Stations Near This Location

Mobil

Mobil 
0.18mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 12
471 NY-17M
Middletown, NY
- - -

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

jayjaytwb6789's avatar image
jayjaytwb6789
May 12 2022
Great Review Icon

okay at best


View Full Station Details
 Details
Pay With GasBuddy Banner
BP

BP 
0.72mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 33
139-147 Wickham Ave
Middletown, NY
$2.91
Price Reporter Icon myles4gmail15 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Restrooms

Reviews

V8SHOMann's avatar image
V8SHOMann
Nov 13 2017
Bad Review Icon

Paid CASH got Credit price at pump


View Full Station Details
 Details
Valero

Valero 
0.73mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 23
217 Wickham Ave
Middletown, NY
$2.91
Price Reporter Icon myles4gmail15 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Air Pump
Lotto

Reviews

conrail172016's avatar image
conrail172016
Oct 09 2023
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Sunoco

Sunoco 
0.75mi

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 35
210 Wickham Ave
Middletown, NY
$2.91
Price Reporter Icon myles4gmail15 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump

Reviews

conrail172016's avatar image
conrail172016
Dec 01 2023
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Exxon

Exxon 
0.78mi

Full StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty StarEmpty Star
 25
1 Fairlawn Ave
Middletown, NY
$2.93
Price Reporter Icon myles4gmail15 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

spat06's avatar image
spat06
Mar 22 2017
Okay Review Icon

cash to credit price is .10 difference. that is ridiculous, compared to others. some don't charge that ridiculous fee per gallon. 20 gallons = $2.00. gotta be making a killing after paying credit card fee.


View Full Station Details
 Details

Top Spotters