Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in Ithaca, NY

Speedway

Speedway 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 179
366 Elmira Rd
Ithaca, NY
$2.85
Price Reporter Icon ducmon2 minutes ago

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Air Pump

Reviews

Buddy_qdf61j3n's avatar image
Buddy_qdf61j3n
Feb 24 2020
Great Review Icon

Great place. Also has a tire pump station.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Byrne Dairy

Byrne Dairy 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 48
323 Elmira Rd
Ithaca, NY
$2.85
Price Reporter Icon ducmon16 minutes ago

Amenities

C-Store
Restrooms

Reviews

ducmon's avatar image
ducmon
Feb 06 2025
Great Review Icon

Good convenience store & deli 👍


View Full Station Details
 Details
Sunoco
APlus

Sunoco 

& APlus
Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 107
210 S Cayuga St
Ithaca, NY
$2.85
Price Reporter Icon WangR14 hours ago

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Air Pump
Payphone

Reviews

ducmon's avatar image
ducmon
Jan 07 2025
Okay Review Icon

Good location. 2 grades of premium gas.


View Full Station Details
 Details
BJ's

BJ's 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 127
40 Graham Rd W
Ithaca, NY
$2.85
Price Reporter Icon WangR14 hours ago

Amenities

Propane
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
Membership Required

Reviews

shermancahal's avatar image
shermancahal
Aug 13 2018
Great Review Icon

Just to reiterate: this is a gas station for BJ members only. All amenities (restroom, etc) are either inside the store or in the auto centre.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Quik Shoppe

Quik Shoppe 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 70
317 3rd St
Ithaca, NY
$2.89
Price Reporter Icon WangR14 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM

Reviews

Buddy_ye40hygr's avatar image
Buddy_ye40hygr
Jun 06 2024
Great Review Icon

Old pumps but gas always cheap owner friendly


View Full Station Details
 Details
CITGO

CITGO 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 61
805 W Buffalo St
Ithaca, NY
$2.99
Price Reporter Icon DataFeed11 hours ago

Amenities

C-Store
Restrooms
ATM
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

ducmon's avatar image
ducmon
Feb 20 2025
Great Review Icon

Good fuel prices


View Full Station Details
 Details
Mirabito

Mirabito 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 208
301 Pine Tree Rd
Ithaca, NY
$3.05
Price Reporter Icon driver1692 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Air Pump

Reviews

driver169's avatar image
driver169
Mar 27 2025
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Byrne Dairy

Byrne Dairy 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 46
208 E Main St
Trumansburg, NY
$3.05
Price Reporter Icon nathanbaker4 hours ago

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Loyalty Discount
Lotto
Beer
Wine

Reviews

driver169's avatar image
driver169
Sep 19 2024
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Mirabito

Mirabito 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 66
600 N Fulton St
Ithaca, NY
$3.05
Price Reporter Icon Ufo34413 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store

Reviews

driver169's avatar image
driver169
Jan 16 2025
Okay Review Icon

Ok


View Full Station Details
 Details
Valero

Valero 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 53
1321 Dryden Rd
Ithaca, NY
$3.05
Price Reporter Icon pjmac91015 hours ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Air Pump

Reviews

Parli32's avatar image
Parli32
Jan 25 2017
Okay Review Icon

Fair variety of products


View Full Station Details
 Details
Click here to earn instant savings of up to $10 every tank!
Click here to download the GasBuddy App and start saving today!

You Are Here

 Home Gas Prices New York Ithaca