Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in New Castle, IN

Sunoco

Sunoco 

Full StarFull StarFull StarEmpty StarEmpty Star
 71
5809 IN-3
Spiceland, IN
$3.09
Price Reporter Icon Tracy05Gray21 hours ago

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Truck Stop
Service Station

Reviews

CACH92's avatar image
CACH92
Jun 05 2023
Bad Review Icon

Horrible place, bad service and if you have a sunoco credit card it won't work here because they are not authorized brand anymore!


View Full Station Details
 Details
GetGo

GetGo 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 53
1206 W Mill
Middletown, IN
$3.15
Price Reporter Icon Owner37 minutes ago

Amenities

Membership Pricing
Pay At Pump
Restaurant
Restrooms
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Lotto
Beer

Reviews

aubreyramsey's avatar image
aubreyramsey
Jul 08 2021
Great Review Icon

Great station with friendly workers.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Marathon

Broad Mart 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 191
1709 E Broad St
New Castle, IN
$3.15
Price Reporter Icon muncie1351 day ago

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Membership Pricing
Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
ATM
Loyalty Discount
Lotto

Reviews

OG_Ghotra1's avatar image
OG_Ghotra1
Jun 22 2024
Great Review Icon

Great customer service and clean store


View Full Station Details
 Details
Sunoco

Sunoco 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 49
603 Broad St
New Castle, IN
$3.15
Price Reporter Icon grgryrc561 day ago
CASH

Amenities

Offers Cash Discount
Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
Payphone
ATM
Service Station
Lotto

Reviews

robincaulk's avatar image
robincaulk
Aug 06 2020
Great Review Icon

Everyone work there seems friendly, gas prices comparable to other stations nearby.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Family Mart

Family Mart 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 101
2400 S Main St
New Castle, IN
$3.19
Price Reporter Icon visitor1 hour ago

Amenities

Propane
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Restrooms
Air Pump
Payphone
ATM
Lotto
Beer
Wine

Reviews

todklo's avatar image
todklo
Dec 26 2019
Great Review Icon

Employees are very courteous and helpful. Very pleasant to stop there.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Shell

Shell 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarEmpty Star
 85
6409 S IN-3
Spiceland, IN
$3.19

Amenities

C-Store
Pay At Pump
Loyalty Discount

Reviews

dakotart1's avatar image
dakotart1
Feb 02 2023
Great Review Icon

Great


View Full Station Details
 Details
Marathon

Marathon 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 44
1909 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN
$3.20
Price Reporter Icon Tracy05Gray21 hours ago

Amenities

Pay At Pump
Air Pump

Reviews

Buddy_vb4md9zz's avatar image
Buddy_vb4md9zz
Jul 19 2024
Okay Review Icon

Gas was expensive, everything else was okay


View Full Station Details
 Details
Casey's

Casey's 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 126
3100 S Memorial Dr
New Castle, IN
$3.24
Price Reporter Icon Owner1 hour ago

Amenities

Air Pump
ATM
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Propane
Restrooms

Reviews

4jof120's avatar image
4jof120
Apr 06 2017
Okay Review Icon

No premium gas, just 89 octane mid grade.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Conoco

Conoco 

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled StarEmpty Star
 52
709 S Main St
New Castle, IN
$3.25
Price Reporter Icon Mainiacres5 hours ago

Amenities

No amenities found.


Reviews

Buddy_wzz64wnm's avatar image
Buddy_wzz64wnm
Sep 30 2024
Great Review Icon

Best place to purchase gasoline, and cigarettes.


View Full Station Details
 Details
Casey's

Casey's 

Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarHalf-filled Star
 101
6643 S Sr-3
Spiceland, IN
$3.29
Price Reporter Icon Owner52 minutes ago

Amenities

Air Pump
ATM
C-Store
Pay At Pump
Propane
Restrooms

Reviews

Punkydee's avatar image
Punkydee
May 20 2021
Great Review Icon

best gas station around the area


View Full Station Details
 Details
Click here to earn instant savings of up to $10 every tank!
Click here to download the GasBuddy App and start saving today!

You Are Here

 Home Gas Prices Indiana New Castle