Check prices faster and save more on gas.
Shell in Watermill (960 Montauk Hwy)
Station Prices
The prices in this row are the prices that members of the GasBuddy community provide.
Prices can also come from store owners and retailer data feeds.
These prices are invaluable to helping one another save the most on fuel!
DataFeedReviews
NONE The pumps are working and there are no signs to tell customers this. Not too bright!!
I come to this gas station during the summer a handful of times because it's the closest station that carries 91 NON-ETHANOL fuel that I use in my SeaDoo watercraft. It's still 51 miles from me so I fill up a lot of cans. They WAY overcharge for it. Last month it was about $4.49/gal. It is genuine non-ethanol fuel. I test it. I have property in Montague NY (Tug Hill region) and there's tons of 91 NON-ETHANOL fuel throughout the entire region up there that many of us use for our snowmobiles and any equipment that sits for long periods unused. At most gas stations up there, you only pay what they charge for super unleaded. Right now at my preferred station up there, the same fuel is about $3.29-$3.39/gal. It is also genuine non-ethanol fuel. I regularly test batches. I know it's largely about supply and demand but give me a break with $4.49/gal. When I go to my house in Montague I always bring back some but that is only every few months. Apart from that, this is a BIG gas station with ma
Not my favorite gas station. Gas prices are decent but I didn't really like the customer service. ATM inside
Convenient location with music and plenty of pumps and maneuverability around the filling islands - convenient location.
