Top 10 Gas Stations & Cheap Fuel Prices in Tompkins County, NY

Just to reiterate: this is a gas station for BJ members only. All amenities (restroom, etc) are either inside the store or in the auto centre.

usually one of the cheaper ones and they pump the gas for you, RARE in NY

Great place. Also has a tire pump station.

Good Dandy convenience store. Competitive fuel prices.

Fair variety of products

Sketchy place. One of the top 5 places Ithaca Police responded to in 2023. Been in the top 10 as far back as public records are available.

Coffee is sitting on burner when less than a cup. Yuck

They turn the pumps off when the station closes and the pumps don’t auto lock so you need to stand at the pump as it fills.

Great discount program with Tops grocery store.

Friendly Employees, decent prices, clean restrooms, hand sanitizer available